By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Close X

Edward Snowden: I'd 'absolutely' do it again

  • NSA whistleblower joined SXSW panel from Russia
  • Snowden: Large-scale online monitoring has been ineffective
  • U.S. Rep. opposed Snowden's appearance, called him 'traitor'
Edward Snowden: I'd 'absolutely' do it again

From somewhere within Vladimir Putin's Russia, NSA leaker and free speech advocate (see that image background?) Edward Snowden spoke with his fellow Americans Monday for the first time since leaving the U.S.

The former CIA employee now charged with espionage, teleconferenced in to a SXSW panel moderated by two members of the ACLU. In a one-hour session -- which included fielding Twitter user-submitted questions and serial advocacy for encrypting personal information -- Snowden covered plenty of ground, discussing online privacy (or lack thereof), national security and, of course, his own decisions.

So what did he say? Here are the highlights:

-- "Would I do it again? Absolutely... I took an oath to defend the Constitution, and I felt the Constitution was being violated on a massive scale."

-- "We've actually had tremendous intelligence failures because we're monitoring the Internet ... everybody's communications, instead of the suspects' communications."

-- "What did we get from bulk collections?... We got nothing."

-- "[Online surveillance programs] are setting fire to the future of the Internet... The people who are in this room now, you're all the firefighters and we need you to help us fix this."

-- "There's a political response that needs to occur, but there's also a tech response that needs to occur."

The crowd was a very welcoming one for the divisive Snowden, who enjoyed frequent applause and praise from the panel hosts, one of whom is his legal advisor. However, it was more of a mixed bag beyond the warm embrace of Austin, where questions and criticism continue about the whistleblower's decision to release confidential U.S. government documents.

Rep. Mike Pompeo (R-KS) wrote a three-page letter to SXSW organizers, calling for the panel to be scrapped. Rep. Pompeo declared that Snowden's only qualifications for a discussion on online monitoring are "his willingness to steal from his own government," called him a "traitor" and pointed out the irony in his seeking asylum in freedom-squeezing Russia.

The letter was mentioned at the beginning of the session by the panel's moderators, who addressed the point on Russia by claiming that if he were in the U.S. instead, Snowden would "be in a solitary cell subject probably to special administrative measures that would prevent him from being able to... participate in the historic debate that he helped launch."

Follow Jonathan Anker on Twitter @JonFromHLN

Refinery29: Lena Dunham expects more from Hollywood

Join the conversation... welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.
Polaroid's new camera: Instant prints, zero ink
Technology | See all 1242 items Polaroid's new camera: Instant prints, zero ink