By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Close X

This is the worst* player in the NFL

  • *As judged by a video game -- albeit a really influential one
  • Broncos' Aaron Brewer is lowest rated of about 2,300 pros
  • The tight end scored just a 69 for Toughness? Wonder what the Toughness rating is for the guy who sets Toughness ratings?
This is the worst* player in the NFL

16 NFL greats who never won the Heisman Trophy

16 NFL greats who never won the Heisman Trophy

Congratulations? College football's weirdest trophies

Congratulations? College football's weirdest trophies

When a nation full of football fans tears into the just-released copies of "Madden 25" this week, they will undoubtedly rush to play the game as Aaron Rodgers and his Green Bay Packers, as Drew Brees and his New Orleans Saints.

Those selecting to play as the Denver Broncos will almost certainly be doing so to play as Peyton Manning. They are most assuredly not doing it to play as Aaron Brewer.

"Aaron Who-er?"

That would be Aaron Brewer, the second-year Denver Bronco who's a virtual NFL unknown. Though that may soon change -- sadly, perhaps, for Brewer. He is the lowest-rated player in all of "Madden 25" (last out of about 2,300 players) and thus now widely regarded as The Worst Player in the NFL.

Sure, it's just a video game that's issuing this determination. But as the only mass-consumed list where players are quantifiably rated (and rankings are obsessed over) the Madden 25 results carry surprising weight. Madden's so-called "Ratings Czar" Donny Moore says players complain to him "all the time" about their ratings.

Brewer's overall rating is 39. For reference, Minnesota Vikings running back Adrian Peterson is tops in the game with a 99. Most players fall somewhere in the mid-60s to mid-80s range. So yeah, that 39 stings.

Photos: Yo, is that a grotto?? Inside Oregon's new football palace

While officially listed as a tight end, Brewer's main role on the team is to play a position most casual football fans have never even heard of: long snapper. This is not a turtle reference. Although the position one must assume to be a long snapper is rather turtle-like. Long snappers are generally NFL afterthoughts, which probably has a lot to do with that 39 and Brewer's unenviable new status.

Of course, declaring someone the "worst player in the NFL" is like calling someone the dumbest person at a cocktail party for Nobel Prize winners. This is an almost impossibly elite group in which to even be included. Of the nation's 1.1 million high school football players, about 1,700 will make it to the pros. That's 0.15%.

With the NFL's annual "cutdown week" now upon us, talented athletes are being tossed aside left and right as teams slash their roster down to the league-mandated 53 players.  Merely surviving this crucible should be applauded. I mean, have you seen "Hard Knocks"? This stuff ain't easy.

Opinion: Why my son will never play football

Brewer would know: He overcame serious odds to make the Broncos last year as an undrafted free agent. UFAs are the ultimate underclass of NFL wannabes. If the league was an old cruise ship, they would be in steerage, bunking six to a room, below deck, battling nausea and rodents, just waiting for the rocky ride to be over.

He came all that way just to land a 39 in Madden?

Looking closer at the ratings: Brewer received a measly 53 for Catching and a relatively very low 69 for Toughness.

Really? For a guy who slams his body against on-rushing 6'3", 250-pound men for a living? Wonder what the Toughness rating is for the guy who figures out Toughness ratings.

Regardless, Aaron Brewer will be the one slipping on that #46 jersey -- even if the number he's more closely associated with this season turns out to be "39."

Follow Jonathan Anker on Twitter @JonFromHLN

Join the conversation... welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.
Watch: NFL cheerleader surprised by Marine hubby!
Gridiron | See all 233 items Watch: NFL cheerleader surprised by Marine hubby!