By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Close X

Judge: Clementi's 'spying' claim not admissible

  • Tyler Clementi commited suicide after his college roomate watched him kissing another man, prosecutors say
  • Clementi's roommate, Dharun Ravi, is accused of accessing webcam from another dorm room, tweeted about what he saw
  • Ravi is on trial for invasion of privacy and bias intimidation
Judge: Clementi's 'spying' claim not admissible

Before Rutgers University freshman Tyler Clementi killed himself, he requested a new single dorm room because, he said, his roommate had spied on him with a webcam.

Ravi is on trial for invading Clementi’s privacy and using his sexuality to intimidate him. Ravi, who shared a dorm room with Clementi, is accused of accessing his webcam in their dorm room from another room down the hall while Clementi was engaged in romantic activity with a man.

On Monday, attorneys sparred over the admissibility of statements made on a online form Clementi filled out requesting the new room on the university’s website. The defense objected to Clementi’s statement on the form accusing Dharun Ravi of spying on him, because it was hearsay.

READ MORE: Get caught up on the Rutgers hate crime trial

Judge Glenn Berman ultimately barred the statement and ordered the prosecution to redact the statement from the form. However, Berman did rule that Clementi’s other statement requesting a new single room will be admissible in court.

Monday’s testimony began with Ravi’s high school friend and Rutgers student Scott Xu taking the stand. Xu testified that he heard Ravi talking about watching his roommate with another man at Ultimate Frisbee practice.

The defense asked Xu about what he had heard about the man that Clementi was interacting with sexually. The judge has ordered that identity of Clementi’s love interest to be protected. Therefore, this man will only be referred to by the initials M.B.

READ MORE: In Session's Jean Casaraz interviews M.B.'s attorney

Xu testified that he had heard M.B. was shady, meaning suspicious. During his opening statement, defense attorney Steven Altman said that various people will describe M.B. as scruffy, shady-looking, slightly over-weight, and having a beard or goatee. 

READ MORE: More details about opening statements in the Rutgers hate crime trial

The defense may argue that Ravi’s motive for spying on Clementi was due to his concerns about a “shady-looking” man being in his dorm room. This could counter the prosecution’s argument that Ravi’s intent to spy on Clementi was in order to use his sexuality to intimidate him.

Cameras are allowed in the courtroom for Ravi's trial, and In Session and HLN will be covering this trial live, so stay tuned.

Join the conversation... welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.